The decision on which financial planning software to use with your practice can be a tough one. Two leaders in the industry are RightCapital and MoneyGuide. Let’s take a look at the differences between them. (Evaluating eMoney? Read this RightCapital vs. eMoney rundown.)
RightCapital vs. MoneyGuide advisor satisfaction ratings
The Kitces Report released in March of 2025, “The Technology That Independent Financial Advisors Actually Use And Like,” shows that RightCapital's overall user satisfaction score grew to 8.7 out of 10, from 8.6 in 2021. MoneyGuide’s rating fell from 8.0 out of 10 in 2022 to 7.9 out of 10, the lowest satisfaction rating of “the big three” financial planning software companies.
The report notes:
RightCapital’s average advisor satisfaction score has surged from 8.0 in 2018 to 8.7 in 2024, tying with Income Lab as the highest-rated program. Conversely, MoneyGuide – after a slight bump in satisfaction between 2020 and 2022 – saw a decline in 2024 (and at a rating of just 7.9, is ranked well below its competitors, signaling a continued decline in market share is likely in the years to come).
The March 2025 T3/Inside Information Advisor Software Survey also revealed that RightCapital (with an average 8.52/10 user rating) was the highest rated software, for the fourth consecutive year. In the most recent survey, MoneyGuide’s rating dropped to 7.67/10 (and its market share dropped significantly from the previous year):
At the time this article was written, G2 ratings for RightCapital were 4.6 out of 5 compared to G2 ratings for MoneyGuide of 4.0 out of 5. G2 reviewers gave RightCapital higher marks for Ease of Use, Quality of Support, and Product Direction, similar to the feedback seen in the Kitces advisor survey.
RightCapital vs. MoneyGuide cost
The cost of RightCapital’s three tiers are laid out on the pricing page. MoneyGuide publishes their pricing on their website as well. It’s worth noting that MoneyGuide is more of an “a la carte'' solution, where you pay extra for certain features, so it’s difficult to do an apples-to-apples pricing comparison.
RightCapital vs MoneyGuide product updates
A June 2023 review on G2 titled “MoneyGuide has not kept up with the times” notes “I have used MGP over the last decade and they have failed to develop any significant additions (phone app, HSA, budgeting,ext.) in that time.”
MoneyGuide is part of Envestnet, which was acquired by private equity firm Bain Capital in 2024. RightCapital is owned by the company’s original founders and remains independent. In the September 2022 social media post above, Michael Kitces notes this difference is how “RightCapital is listening to advisors”.
Another advisor, Scott Frey, raves about RightCapital’s ability to take feedback from advisors and make changes: “When we went to MoneyGuide with problems, we got a ‘we’ve got bigger fish to fry’ message. RightCapital…took feedback as well as a technology company has in my experience.”
RightCapital vs. MoneyGuide functionality
Planning approach
There are some major differences between RightCapital and MoneyGuidePro, the main one being that with MoneyGuidePro advisors must use the goal-based planning approach. According to this article by industry expert Michael Kitces, goal-based planning “puts the cart before the horse” and may result in hard conversations with the client about needing to create more realistic goals. With RightCapital, advisors have the flexibility to use goal-based planning, cash-flow planning, plus modified cash-flow planning.
Data sources used in financial planning
RightCapital considers more data sources than MoneyGuidePro does. People’s lives are complex, that’s why RightCapital includes budgeting, and debt and student loan management tools built within the software to envision a client’s entire financial picture, and accounts for clients’ spending habits such as when they are spending more than they make within a given year. These additional inputs and tools provide more control for the advisor to help clients with their specific financial situations.
MoneyGuidePro, on the other hand, has minimal consideration of pre-retirement income and expenses. MoneyGuidePro assumes that clients are not spending more than they make in a given year.
Tax considerations
RightCapital notes all income sources and how each is taxed. To fund any deficits, RightCapital also considers drawing down and selling assets, which produce unique tax scenarios.
RightCapital offers an interactive Roth conversion tool that makes it easy to visualize the impact of conversions on items such as IRMMA surcharges and increases to taxable Social Security. While MoneyGuidePro has Roth conversions, it lacks the interactivity and visual outputs. RightCapital also includes future tax projections including sample tax forms such as the 1040.
Even more recent tax-planning updates to RightCapital include Tax Strategies, which solves for the top asset location, withdrawal, and Roth conversion strategies based on the client plan, and Tax Analyzer, a tool in which you can upload client tax forms for further analysis.
Data visualization tools
RightCapital offers data visualizations that are much clearer than the alternative solutions. For example, RightCapital received a lot of press and advisor approval about the one-page plan, Snapshot. MoneyGuide also offers a “digital page summary” called “My Snapshot."
According to the advisor replies to the above post from Michael Kitces, it seems RightCapital is more preferred, with quotes such as “Design wise RC crushes,” “I can’t tell you how much RightCapital’s illustration of future wealth distribution warms my heart,” and “MGP and eMoney reports look like they should come with a fax cover sheet.”
Other exciting visualization features from RightCapital include Blueprint™—an engaging, intuitive, and interactive graphical layout of each clients’ net worth, goals, income, savings, and expenses—and Cash Flow Maps— intuitive visuals that help illustrate your clients' cash inflows and outflows in a simple diagram, which advisors were excited to see:
In the 2023 Kitces survey, RightCapital earned a 8.8/10 over MoneyGuide’s 7.5/10 for Visuals, which was a category not included in this year’s report.
Additional differences
RightCapital also has the following features that are not available within MoneyGuidePro:
Fully integrated risk assessment tool with customizable questionnaires
Budgeting
Annuity analysis
Document vault
Back office access
Consolidated client activity tracking
RightCapital vs. MoneyGuide user experience
Advisor Scott Frey said MoneyGuide “is a relic of the nineties,’ stressing his disappointment in having to take time in client meetings to explain the software—and sometimes even having to vouch for its reliability. “The UI (user interface) was unintuitive to say the least.”
Advisor Jonathan Kiehl had used MoneyGuide with a previous firm before starting his own RIA and switching to RightCapital. It “didn’t really sit well with me” to send clients off on their way with a 60-page report, he said. During a Good Advisors Finish First panel held in 2023, Jonathan discussed the differences he found between RightCapital and MoneyGuide:
Diving more into the cohesiveness of RightCapital, Jonathan noted, “It looks the same whether I'm presenting a financial plan, or whether clients are logging into their client portal to see their net worth statement, or to do some work with the budgeting tool…When I was with MoneyGuide, a lot of the things were add-ons…it was a little disjointed.”
RightCapital vs. MoneyGuide integrations
At the time of this blog publication, according to the Ezra Group WealthTech Integration Scores, the robustness of RightCapital’s external integrations is rated higher than MoneyGuide’s. RightCapital integrates with more than 40 other wealthtech companies including analytics platforms, CRMs, custodians, clearing firms, and performance reporting tools.
RightCapital vs. MoneyGuide client support
In the aforementioned Kitces Report, RightCapital rated highest for Customer Support with 9.1 out of 10 compared to MoneyGuide’s 7.8 out of 10. At the time of this post, according to the user surveys collected on G2, the overall quality of support is rated as 9.5 out of 10 for RightCapital vs 7.5 out of 10 for MoneyGuide. All support inquiries to RightCapital are answered by a live product specialist.
RightCapital vs. MoneyGuide onboarding experience
Several advisor success stories mention how simple the learning process was when starting to use RightCapital:
“It was extremely easy,” Brooke Martinez commented, when asked about switching to RightCapital.
The Optima Capital Management team stated that within a week of using the software, it was clear, “RightCapital is so much smoother to work with.”
Michael Johnson, of Alchemi Wealth, mentioned in February 2025’s RightInsights event: “RightCapital was probably the easiest integration that we've had to date. We have done probably 15 different data migrations over the last four years. It can be really complex at times, but it truly was a click of a button with RightCapital.”
Some MoneyGuide reviewers on G2 comment on the difficulty of getting started. This otherwise good review notes, “There are so many different tools/scenarios it can be cumbersome at times.”
Choosing a financial planning software for your practice is a big decision. We encourage you to sign up for a personalized 1:1 20-minute demo with a member of the sales team and test drive RightCapital during a 14-day free trial.